I would still be asking for her birth control pills. Would love to see the look on her face when I start dropping one by one down the sink.
After all, it would be her decision whether to hand them over.
Would take missing more than a couple of pills to get pregnant. She would have to stop taking them altogether.
So the next time she whispers that into your ear, whisper back to her to hand over her birth control.
Did she take money? Then she would be a whore? And if she did, Is she asking you for permission to continue?
If not, then she’s a slut. But probably still asking you to continue.
Either way, you should encourage her
Start with someone neither of you know. Going from fantasy to reality is a big step. Just in case you decide it’s not for you, it’s easier that acquaintances not know.